﷽

al-Ḥamdulillāh I was invited again by the gracious folks at Masjid al-Fatiha of America, located in Azusa, California. I’ve worked closely with this family-run masjid for years.

al-Salām ‘alaykum everyone. Just a few words on the recent phenomenon of allegedly fake AI videos of war criminals and what we should think of that.

Subscribe now

Get more from Imam Marc Manley in the Substack app

Available for iOS and Android

Get the app

The following are some words I put together regarding a discussion at ifṭār the other night:

المسلم المعاصر في خُسران من وجوه كثيرة، ومن أبرزها أنّه يتفكّر كإنسان مغلوب. فبدلا من أن يذُمّ نفسه ينظر إلى الآخرين: مثلا الكفار أو اليهود. ولا ينظر إلى نفسه؛ فيُسقط مشكلاته كلها على الآخرين ولكن الأسلوب القرآني أن يَدينَ الإنسان نفسه. وإضافة إلى ذلك لا يرى في…

Read more

Let’s take a quick look at the rules which apply to numbers and counting objects.

Numbers One and Two

Read more

Many Muslims today speak of “love”: for Allāh, for the Prophet ‎ﷺ, etc. And while having love for Allāh and the Prophet ‎ﷺ are indeed noble ambitions it would also seem that the current emphasis on love has come at the cost how we see obedience. It would seem for some Muslims today that talk of fearing Allāh and striving for obedience is akin to negativity. Others have conflated love with mercy. But the Qur’ān, however, addresses these qualities quite differently and separately.

If we examine how the Qur’ān commands us to fear Allāh, such admonitions are unencumbered and straightforward. In contrast love is conditional:

or that there are those that Allāh loves, and those He doesn’t:

and

In other words love—especially love to Allāh and/or His Prophet ‎ﷺ is proven through devotional commitment (ittibāʿ) and obedience (ṭāʿah), not merely self-selecting sentiment.

As for mercy (raḥmah), Allāh says that it encompasses everything:

In fact, Allāh’s mercy—in this life—extends even to those who don’t believe in Him or even reject Him outright. Yes, Allāh shows mercy to the believer and the non-believer alike (though not necessarily equally). In fact, as we leaned in our Satuday ʿaqīdah class, Allāh’s mercy can be understood as having two branches if you will: the aforementioned all-encompassing mercy for everything and everyone in this life, and a specially mercy reserved for those who believe in Him for the Next Life. The point being here is that we should not collapse mercy into love.

A great example of this is the sotry of Qarūn (Korah, in the Bible). His story illustrates how misplaced love—especially of wealth—can blind judgment. Those around him admired him, even coveting to be in his place. But when Allāh caused the earth to swallow him, they realized that Allāh alone expands and constricts provision. In fact, in the Qālūn (Madanī) reading of the 82nd verse, we see an additional highlight that differs from the Ḥafṣ reading,

in the reading according to Qālūn, it becomes,

In the latter case, the verb in the passive voice underscores our powerlessness and the need for fear in order to sober and reorientate our hearts.

So much of today’s “spiritual” discourse turns faith into a dopamine-trap where we seek to obtain, or in some cases, avoid, a certain mood. On this treadmill of mood chasing fear is always “bad,” love is always “good.” But what we are in need of today isn’t just obtaining the perfect “vibe” but instead, we need to be taught the skills which are necessary and conducive to contemplation and reflection. We need to return to a knowledge-based engagement with the Book of Islām which means we’re going to have to study. Systematic study. Yes, we’re going to have to learn the language of revelation—Arabic—because everything in our Dīn flows from the Qur’ān in its language (as well as the Sunnah). These sciences of revelation are not the tools of gatekeepers; they are the tools by which we can authentically and effectively contemplate (tadabbur) and reflect (tafakkur) with consistency and discipline, not just sentiment.

It goes without saying that we all need an emotional bond with the Qur’ān but feelings built on hawa (emotions/passions) and speculation won’t suffice in and of themselves. Real attachment grows out of consistent and rigorous learning. Beware of performative “piety” that entertains yet leaves you without acquiring the tools to learn. Seek teachers who impart methods, not just stories. The onus is on you to choose paths and mentors that raise the waterline of knowledge so you can truly engage this Book with is “guidance for the God-fearing” (hudan lil-Muttaqīn).

This short talk is meant as an invitation, not an admonition. A pray that we can all build a sturdy foundation of knowledge from which love can spring deep from within that well.

Ask yourself: why would anyone settle for junk when a far greater feast awaits? I wrestle with this analogy every time I take my daughter for sushi. Once she came to know “the good stuff” she’s no longer satisfied with grocery store sushi. Only the good stuff.

Read more

There’s no doubt that modern psychology and psychotherapy have influenced and changed how people think about God and their religious traditions. Muslims are no different in this matter. In fact, the only question which remains is to what extent is the impact and what might be the remedy and how we might return to a more authentic understanding of the …

Read more

Modern political rhetoric, on the Right and the Left, share a common trait: they are both proponents of victimization ideologies. For the Left, chief amongst their grievances are the transgressions of white people. The legitimate protests and resistance against white supremacy have come to form a kind of secular telos for the Left; an end in and of it…

Read more

There are many challenges to modern life which Muslims have to face. One particularly daunting challenge is the challenge of modern psychoanalysis and its impact on how Muslims understand Islām, themselves, and morality in the modern world. But Muslims are not alone in this challenge and a great many western academics from various religious and secula…

Read more

This video is an excerpt from my Saturday class on ʿaqīdah (creed and beliefs), discusses how the "problem" of good and evil are understood and resolved via the guiding light of the Qur’ān and the Sunnah.

Read more

Welcome to Episode 46 of the Middle Ground Podcast. In this episode I want to discuss a new (and disturbing) trend I’ve noticed in the social media landscape, namely Muslims making videos in which they claim the non-practicing Muslims are somehow actually “doing Islām more” than those who do. Can this be true? You can listen to the audio podcast or watch the video below.

Welcome to Episode 45 of the Middle Ground Podcast. For this episode I’m sharing an excerpt from my Saturday class on ʿaqīdah, otherwise known as “creed”; i.e., the things we Muslims must believe in and things we must reject. But the study of ʿaqīdah is much more than a list of do’s and don’ts. It should ultimately impact our character as well. I share a anecdote of a lesson I recently learned while visiting my 92-year-old father in the hospital.

I was recently asked a question by a student who was attending another study session in which the teacher quoted a ḥadīth of the Prophet ‎ﷺ in which he stated ‎ﷺ,

Read more

There are many milestones and areas of proficiency students of Arabic seek. Chief amongst them is the ability to read without the vowel markings (tashkīl/ḥarakāt). And while vocabulary acquisition plays an important role in that so does knowing some of the finer points of grammar. For this short lesson, let’s look at another such milestone: the active…

Read more

Welcome to Episode 44 of the Middle Ground Podcast. Today, while driving to Jumu’ah, I wanted to share some thoughts of mine on the state of Muslim thinking and politics particularly as it relates to Zohran Mamdani’s bid for NYC mayor and the need for American Muslims to mature in their religious, and political, thinking.

Welcome to Episode 43 of the Middle Ground Podcast. Today I want to discuss the current paradox we’re living in: the paradox of “infinite” digital options. This paradox has left many (if not most) us more distracted, less fulfilled, and suffering from a kind of spiritual malnutrition. Friedrich Nietzsche, the 19th Century philosopher, presaged the age of the “smart”-phone by warning of the dangers of losing our will to exert ourselves against external forces. What he foretold of nihilism now manifests as endless scrolling: a flood of content that means nothing, an curated attrition.

Our minds and more specifically, our hearts, overwhelmed by choice and a dearth of serendipity, have succumbed, resigning us to a doom of passive consumption. We confuse abundance with freedom, but true freedom requires boundaries. Algorithms, despite the ubiquitous presence, are neither neutral or natural; they inform our desires and corral us into predictable patterns like lambs for the slaughter.

But Nietzsche’s vision of the Übermensch is not the answer. After all, he is famously attributed to the statement, “Gott ist tot/God is dead”. What we need today is not the Übermensch but the muḥsin, the one who creates values and lives by them, striving for God’s pleasure as if he sees God, though in spite of not being able to do so, the muḥsin knows God sees him. In todays context this will undoubtedly include a reclaiming of our attention. We must strive to align our habits, digital, analog, and otherwise, with our highest values, namely Islām, not our lowest impulses.

What I’m advocating for here, with all due respect to Cal Newport, shouldn’t be misconstrued as a kind of digital minimalism; it's precisely an Islāmic and spiritual resistance. The Qur'ān isn't an echo chamber; it's a resonance chamber. Echoes repeat cacophonously. Resonance transforms you.

We must build a digital philosophy grounded in Islām: rooted in submission (Islām), faith (Īmān), and excellence (Iḥsān). This means creating principles for tech use that serve our goal of achieving Jannah (Paradise), not endless, short-lived dopamine hits.

In an age where every scroll is tracked, then perhaps the revolutionary act is to stop and choose. Real freedom is not infinite content; it is deliberate attention, guided by purpose.

Recommended Actions:

1. Digital Intention Journal: Before opening any app, write down your purpose and time limit. Reflect after.

2. Algorithmic Sabbaticals: One day a week, consume only human-recommended content.

3. Information Sanctuaries: Designate time for deep, distraction-free engagement with one source.

4. Digital Containers: Set fixed times (e.g., 30 mins a.m./p.m.) for digital use.

5. Create Islamic Digital Principles: Define three tech-use rules aligned with Islām, Īmān, and Iḥsān.

6. Weekly Discovery Day: Seek novelty outside the algorithm: libraries, friends, strangers, random tools.

7. Choose Content in Advance: Decide what to watch/read before opening apps.

8. Reframe Tech Use as Worship: Ask: does this tool help me emulate the Prophet?

9. Reclaim Will to Power: Choose what nourishes you—not what hooks you.

10. Embrace Constraints: Boundaries don’t limit creativity; they make it possible.

There are many milestones for students to achieve in their pursuit of studying the Arabic language. One of those is the ability to identify when a verb is being used in the active and passive voices, particularly in the present tense. Below is a short summary and guide to provide, in shā’ Allāh, some useful hints towards achieving that goal.

Read more

In Arabic, not all visits are created equal.

For instance, let’s take the verb zāra (زار), “he visited.” While its meaning is clear in a general sort of way, it is somewhat vague as to how often. Additionally, there’s no indication as to whether or not they’ll come back. It's the language of a (maybe) one-time guest, like an awkward cousin or uncle who…

Read more

Welcome back to the Middle Ground Podcast with Episode 42. Here, Imam Marc Manley takes into an important—and uncomfortable topic—that continues to stir headlines and town hall debates across America: Sharī’ah law. The issue here is not the fears and concerns of non-Muslims; as Imam Marc states, it’s not the obligation of Muslims to make non-Muslims comfortable with Muslims and Islām. Instead, the problem is the caricature of sharī’ah that’s being presented as factual in political campaigns and viral fear-mongering social media videos. This episode endeavors to unpack what Sharī’ah really means for Muslims, especially Muslims living in a non-Muslim society and how Sharī’ah shapes the personal lives of Muslims (and maybe even influencing not public laws), challenging the caricature and assumption that Sharī’ah is something always to be “imposed” upon others (a misconception even some Muslims have bought into).

You’ll hear a candid conversation on the difference between divine and secular law, as well as how fear of Islam shapes not just social opinions but public and governmental policy, and what it means to confidently assert your faith without compromise. Whether you’re Muslim, Christian, or just trying to make sense of religion in modern America, this is one you don’t want to miss.